Cast Iron Vs Stainless Steel

Cast iron vs stainless steel is nowadays one of the most popular discussions for industrial appliances. Both cast iron and cast steel play a remarkable role in various industries.

Cast iron is a metal with a high quantity of carbon. On the other hand, stainless steel is an alloy with a low carbon content and a high chromium quantity. Both cast iron and stainless steel provide unique properties and advantages. Each of them is popular for individual applications. Therefore, understanding cast iron vs stainless steel is crucial for making informed decisions. It will also help your project choose a suitable metal for the job.

Considering that importance, we have prepared this article discussing the primary differences. This article aims to provide comprehensive details on their properties and advantages. It will also highlight the best use for each metal in various applications. Therefore, whether you use your metal for construction, manufacturing, or other purposes, this guide will help you. However, you can navigate below and find the summary. Here, we have discussed the primary differences in a table. We hope it would be a quick solution to understand the primary differences between cast iron vs stainless steel.

Cast Iron

invester

Cast Iron is an iron-carbon alloy with a carbon content greater than 2%. It is a versatile and popular material in various industries, from construction to manufacturing. However, some of the most common properties of cast iron are:

  • This metal provides high thermal conductivity.
  • Cast iron is resistant to deformation and impact.
  • Low melting point (1145~1250℃) and small shrinkage during solidification, which makes cast iron have good casting performance and fluidity, and can be easily molded into various metal shapes.
  • The compressive strength and hardness are close to carbon steel, but the plasticity is poor, the structure is uneven, and the weldability is poor. This is because cast iron has a high carbon content, which makes it mechanically brittle.
  • Good wear resistance, especially ductile iron, which has excellent wear resistance due to its spherical graphite microstructure.
  • The casting performance and cutting processing are better.
  • Cast iron materials can withstand high temperature and high pressure working environments, so they have high durability and reliability. But this also results in a larger weight of the cast iron.

Cast iron is famous in various applications. Some of the most common applications are:

  • Water supply, sewage, and drainage systems parts
  • Automotive parts, such as cylinder heads, crankshafts, engine blocks
  • Construction equipment such as maintenance hole covers, and railings
  • Agricultural equipment such as cultivators and plows
  • Machine bases and frames
  • Cooking equipment, such as plans, skillets, and Dutch ovens

Limitations

  • Cast iron is brittle and prone to cracking under high pressure.
  • It provides relatively poor tensile strength and flexibility. As a result, it is suitable for applications where flexibility is a concern.
  • If the protective oxide is damaged, cast iron is susceptible to rusting.
  • Cast iron is relatively heavier and denser compared to other materials. As a result, it is not suitable for applications where weight is a concern
  • It can be challenging to weld on cast iron. The high carbon content and low flexibility make it difficult to repair.

Stainless Steel

Stainless steel is also a versatile material with many valuable properties. These characteristics of stainless steel make it suitable for various applications. Although it also has some limitations, which must be considered when selecting it for use in specific applications. Here are some of the most common characteristics are:

  • Stainless steel contains a minimum of 10.5% of chromium. This chromium content quickly reacts with oxygen to form a protective layer on the surface. As a result, it becomes highly resistant to corrosion and rust.
  • It is a strong and durable material. Therefore, it is suitable for applications where high strength is a concern.
  • Stainless steel can withstand high temperatures making it suitable for extreme temperature applications.
  • It is easy to clean. As a result, it is ideal for use in hygiene-sensitive industries. The food and pharmaceutical industries are the most popular in this list.
  • Stainless steel has a shiny, reflective surface. It gives stainless steel an attractive appearance. Therefore, it is ideal for architectural and decorative applications.

The above properties make stainless steel ideal for various industries. Here are some of the most popular applications of stainless steel:

  • Food and beverage applications, such as tanks, pipes, and processing machinery
  • Architectural and construction applications, such as cladding, roofing, and structural components
  • Automotive and transportation applications, such as exhaust systems and body parts
  • Medical and pharmaceutical industry equipment
  • Oil and gas industry for use in harsh environments

Limitations

  • Stainless steel is comparatively more expensive than other materials. As a result, it is not suitable for cost-sensitive applications.
  • It may be corrosive to specific environments, such as high levels of chlorides or acids.
  • Stainless steel is sometimes challenging to machine. Consequently, it also increases the manufacturing cost of other products.
  • Stainless steel is brittle at low temperatures. As a result, it is not suitable for cryogenic applications.
  • Some grades of stainless steel are magnetic, which can limit their use in specific applications.

Cast iron vs Stainless Steel

When comparing cast iron vs stainless steel, both are better for unique applications. In the following, we have pointed out some most common factors considered in most applications of these metals. We will determine which one is better for the individual purpose.

Heat Retention

Cast iron has a relatively high heat retention capacity. It can absorb and retain heat for a long time. This characteristic makes cast iron suitable for cooking applications that require constant temperature. On the other hand, stainless steel has a comparatively lower heat retention capacity. However, it has a faster heat-up time and can distribute heat more evenly than cast iron.

Which one is better? It depends on the specific application. Cast iron is best for applications that require constant and even heat sources. On the other hand, stainless steel is better for applications that require precise control and a faster heat-up time.

Ease of Care: Maintenance And Cleaning

Regarding ease of care, cast iron and stainless steel differ. Cast iron is more susceptible to rusting. As a result, it requires a bit more care and maintenance than stainless steel. However, cast iron requires seasoning with oil to create a non-stick surface. Soap is not recommended for washing cast iron surfaces as it strips the seasoning.

On the other hand, stainless steel is much easier to care for than cast iron. It is non-reactive and won’t rust. As a result, there is no need to season for rust protection. Which one is better? Stainless steel is indeed the clear winner regarding ease of care.

Durability

Both cast iron and stainless steel are highly durable materials. However, cast iron is a brittle material prone to cracking under sudden impacts or thermal shocks. Although, cast iron is highly resistant to wear and tear. On the other hand, stainless steel is a robust and malleable material. It is less prone to cracking or chipping than cast iron. It is highly resistant to corrosion and staining.

Which one is better? Both cast iron and stainless steel are the winner for specific applications. In contrast, cast iron may be suitable for cooking applications. On the other hand, stainless steel may be ideal for industrial or commercial applications.

Tensile And Compression Strength

Cast iron is a brittle material. It is highly resistant to compression but has lower tensile strength than steel. It is prone to cracking under sudden impacts and thermal shocks. However, cast iron’s strength depends on the casting process’s quality. On the other hand, stainless steel is a robust and ductile material. It is highly resistant to bending, stretching, and compressing. Adding nickel, molybdenum, and titanium enhances its strength and durability.

Which one is better? Regarding tensile and compression strength, stainless steel has better stability than cast iron. As a result, stainless steel is better for applications where high strength and durability are critical. Some of the most common applications include construction and manufacturing.

Budget

Regarding the budget, the cost of cast iron and stainless steel may vary depending on the product and quality. Cast iron can typically range from relatively inexpensive to quite expensive, depending on the quality and brand. In this case, higher-quality cast iron products may be made of higher-quality materials. On the other hand, stainless steel is more expensive than cast iron due to the higher cost of materials and manufacturing process. Stainless steel products may range from $20 to several hundred dollars.

Which one is better? Cast iron is less expensive than stainless steel. However, the quality of materials and manufacturing process may significantly affect the cost. Therefore, the better choice depends on the intended application.

Summary

Cast iron and stainless steel are both popular in every metal industry. Starting from construction to manufacturing everywhere requires these two metals. But the question is, which sector specializes in which metal? In this case, you should know the cast iron vs stainless steel differences. In the following, we have made a quick summary table on cast iron vs stainless steel.

Table 1 Cast Iron vs Stainless Steel Difference Table

PropertiesCast IronStainless steel
Material CompositionIron alloy with high carbon contentSteel alloy chromium and nickel content
WeightHeavyLighter than cast iron
DurabilitydurableDurable
Rust ResistanceProne to rustResistant to rust
Heat retentionExcellent heat retention capabilityPoor heat retention
Heat distributionUneven heat distributionEven heat distribution
Cooking surfaceA porous and uneven surfaceSmooth and even surface
SeasoningRequires seasoning to prevent rust and improve non-stick propertiesIt doesn’t require additional seasoning
MaintenanceRequires regular seasoning, handwashing, and careful dryingEasy to clean and can be put in the dishwasher
PriceComparatively InexpensiveComparatively more expensive

Dawang Casting is one of the leading casting foundries in the world. They produce the most common metal castings necessary for primary application in every industry. Cast iron and stainless steel are two primary metals of them. However, don’t hesitate to ask them any questions about their products. Indeed, they keep one of the best customer service teams eager to help you.